Does Captain Kirk’s Appearance Change Pike’s Future on ‘Strange New Worlds?’

Paul Wesley made his debut as the iconic sci-fi character Captain James T. Kirk  in the season one finale of the Paramount+ series  “A Quality of Mercury,” which is a brilliant mirror of the classic Star Trek: The Original Series episode, “Balance of Terror.”

But what does this all mean about about Captain Pike’s ultimate fate?

Everything that happens in this episode is meant to parallel the events of “Balance of Terror,” only this time, it asks the question: what if Pike was still captain and not Kirk? For those who have watched “Balance of Terror” a billion times, this will be obvious, right down to moments in which the dialogue is identical.

If you’re still confused as to how Pike can be playing out the events of a TOS episode in which he was not originally a part of, Spock actually explains it pretty perfectly: “All that we can surmise is that in the Prime future, some other captain of the Enterprise must have commanded it differently.”

In “Balance of Terror,” Kirk defeated the Romulan ship through quick thinking (and a lot of luck), which convinced the Romulans the Federation was a serious rival that shouldn’t be attacked outright. Essentially, in “Balance of Terror,” the Romulans tested Starfleet and Starfleet passed the test. In “A Quality of Mercy,” Starfleet fails the test and the result is war.

Wesley talked to The Hollywood Reporter prior to the season finale, explaining how much he appreciated Shatner’s blessing and explores how he approached his Captain Kirk, including the lesson he took from riding motorcycles. He also talks about how he landed the top-secret role and teases how season two will better flesh out the relationship between Kirk and his brother, Samuel.

The casting process was so secretive for others who I’ve interviewed, so I can’t even imagine how locked down it was for you. Tell me about how this happened?  It was so secretive! It happened so quickly that I thought it was a prank because it was literally a call from my agent over the weekend saying, “Hey, do you want to do a quick zoom with [showrunners] Akiva and Henry and casting directors?” I said, “Yeah, of course. Do you know what is this for?” And they were like, “It’s a character who is very iconic in Star Trek, just talk to them and see what happens.” So, we did this Zoom, and we all just had a great time. The episode had not been written yet, but they knew they wanted Kirk to come in. So, there was no material, it was just kind of a general conversation about everything you can imagine. And that was it. Then it was literally like, “You’re leaving next week.” (Laughs.)

That’s wild. After you booked it, how did you go about developing your own iteration of such a classic sci-fi character? Did you want any vestiges from Mr. Shatner in this Kirk?

The most important aspect is to not do an imitation of something that is sacred. And obviously William Shatner’s interpretation of Captain Kirk has really touched people; it’s been important to people for a variety of reasons. I think the most important thing is to not do an imitation because it’s an insult to the character who is so iconic — and it’s a reminder that I’m not William Shatner. (Laughs.) So, this is a version of Kirk we’ve never seen, and every episode is different.

Obviously, the season one finale is an alternate timeline that doesn’t exist, because it takes place in the future. He’s not captain of the Enterprise. He’s never met Spock, and he’s never had all those experiences. It’s a Kirk who has been shaped differently. So in the season finale, it really was open to interpretation. In season two, we meet a Kirk who we know better. I think the most important thing was to pay respect to the important pillars of his personality: His morality, his incredible instinct, his courage, his empathy towards others and how protective he is of his crew.

How was putting on that costume for the first time — overwhelming? Empowering? Mind-blowing?

(Laughs.) All of those words are pretty accurate. Television moves rapidly, and so even just sitting in the chair — I rewatched every TOS episode, trying to understand the posture or where to put my hands — really just feeling at home in this chair. I ride motorcycles and when you first get on a motorcycle, you don’t really understand how it moves, and you don’t really understand how to do nice tight turns. You don’t feel comfortable. And it’s like that with the chair, how you’re just sitting there. That was one of the things that I needed to understand, so it felt like I had been sitting there thousands of times. And it’s like that in this outfit. I know this outfit; I feel at home in it.

We never saw much of Kirk’s brother, Samuel, in TOS other than Shatner briefly in a mustache, so it has been a lot of fun seeing more of him on SNW. Have you and Dan Jeannotte developed a nice bond? Will that relationship be explored more?

Dan is wonderful, and it was very easy for me to immediately have this kind of brotherly connection with him. I don’t know how to describe it. But with that said, we will explore this in future episodes, particularly in season two. I don’t want to tease too much, but there is a rivalry between the two of them because they’re quite different. There is competitiveness. They both want to impress their father and it’s hard when Kirk has achieved so much, so quickly. It’s hard for Samuel to be able to deal with that.

And finally, I knew fans flipped when Shatner gave you his blessing via Twitter after you two happened to fly together. I assume that does wonders for the nerves and any anxiety with stepping into Kirk’s shoes. How did you feel?

How classy of him. He didn’t have to do that. We did have a lovely conversation on the plane, but you know, he didn’t have to do that. He went out of his way to tweet “best of luck and congrats,” which really just meant so much. You can’t even imagine how much that meant to me. He hadn’t seen what we were doing, but gave me his blessing to enjoy this character. And for me, that meant everything.

Pike and the crew of the Enterprise face an unprecedented threat which could change the Federation forever in the season finale of #StarTrek #StrangeNewWorlds! pic.twitter.com/NAVzz17Jga

— Star Trek on Paramount+ (@StarTrekOnPPlus) July 2, 2022

Star Trek: Strange New Worlds is streaming on Paramount+.